Skip to content

The Old Rules vs. The New Rules

Conversation Marketing Handbook Cover

Marketing used to be about control. Brands controlled the message, the timing, the channel — and often, the customer had little say in the matter. It was all about reach, repetition, and recall. The louder you were, the more you stood out.

That world is fading.

Today, we’ve entered an era where responsiveness beats repetition, and relevance trumps reach. Customers don’t want to be broadcasted at — they want dialogue. They want a seat at the table. And they expect brands to listen, learn, and respond.

The Old Rules

The old way of doing things relied on a few core assumptions:

  • Message first, audience second
    Craft the campaign, then push it to as many people as possible.

  • Mass media equals mass success
    TV, radio, billboards, email blasts — big spend meant big impact.

  • One message fits all
    Personalisation was expensive and rare. Most messages were generic.

  • Control the brand narrative
    Conversations were seen as risky. PR teams managed reputation from the top down.

  • Success means impressions and reach
    If it got seen or heard, it was working — even if no one cared.

The New Rules

In the era of Conversation Marketing, those assumptions no longer hold up. The most effective marketers follow a new set of principles:

  • Audience first, message second
    Start with understanding — use data, personas, and context to shape the message.

  • Be present where your audience is active
    Messaging apps, chatbots, voice assistants, forums — not just inboxes and ad slots.

  • Speak with, not at
    Encourage interaction. Make space for questions, feedback, and co-creation.

  • Personalise at scale using AI
    Tailor responses in real time based on behaviours, preferences, and needs.

  • Measure relationships, not just reach
    Focus on meaningful engagement — sentiment, satisfaction, and loyalty.

Before and After

Here’s a quick comparison of how the shift looks in practice:

Traditional Marketing Conversation Marketing
Broadcast to large audiences Engage individuals in real time
One-size-fits-all campaigns Personalised, context-aware messages
Message-driven, campaign-based Dialogue-driven, always-on interactions
Focus on impressions and clicks Focus on relationships and relevance
Brand speaks, customer listens Brand listens, customer participates

Why This Matters

If you're still operating by the old rules, you're no longer just behind — you're invisible. Modern consumers filter out noise, ignore generic ads, and expect brands to meet them where they are with something that feels human.

Making the shift isn’t just smart — it’s necessary.

“People don’t buy products. They buy relationships, stories, and experiences.”
Seth Godin


Next: Why Now?